AI Peekaboo is the best Gumshoe AI alternative for agencies and teams tracking several client brands or product lines because one subscription can cover those brands and white-label reports begin at $100 a month. Choose Profound if you lead a large enterprise AEO, content or PR team, and stay with Gumshoe when buyer-persona analysis across several roles is the requirement you can’t give up.
Gumshoe gives teams a distinct way to examine AI visibility. Its Visibility Audit breaks a category into buyer personas, prompts and topics, then shows how AI platforms describe your brand to each audience. A B2B company selling to procurement leaders, operations teams and technical buyers can use that structure to see whether one group receives weaker recommendations than another.
The problem starts when an agency adds clients or when one company tracks several product lines. Gumshoe bills its Starter plan at $99 a month and Pro at $299 a month, per project. A project is a brand plus a focus area, so your agency pays again for every client or product line.
Our Gumshoe AI review covers what each plan includes. The right replacement tracks the buyer questions you care about, reports on every brand you manage and hands your team its next task.
What changes when you replace Gumshoe
Gumshoe organizes paid accounts around projects and persona-led audits. Most alternatives organize capacity around brands, prompts, workspaces or total checks. Projects mean your bill grows with every client, and you need to check whether reporting fits your agency’s delivery.
Tool
Best fit
Starting price
Multi-brand setup
Buyer-persona segmentation
Reporting and action
AI Peekaboo
Agencies
$30/month
One subscription can cover multiple brands
No
White-label reports and client links from $100/month, recommendations
Av. António Augusto de Aguiar 122C 1050-046 Lisboa, Portugal
Minnesota
202 N Cedar Ave, Suite 1 Owatonna, MN 55060, USA
Agency workspaces available
No persona filter stated
Enterprise workflows, agents and API on Enterprise
Scrunch
Mid-size and larger brands
$250/month
One brand per subscription, Agency Core has 3 workspaces
Core: 1 persona; Enterprise: custom
Insights, recommendations, page audits and agent traffic
Peec AI
In-house marketing and SEO teams
€85/month
Projects depend on plan
Personas included in prompt work
Daily tracking, Actions and source analytics
Otterly
Lean teams
$29/month
Unlimited workspaces from Standard
None stated
Recommendations, exports and agency reporting through Looker Studio
LLM Pulse
Single-brand teams
€49/month weekly
1 project on Starter
None stated
Scale adds custom reports and API
Surfer
Content teams already using Surfer
€95/month
5 brand workspaces on AI Search Analytics
None stated
AI Tracker beside its content workflow
Agency economics are easier to see with a simple example. The Gumshoe rows assume one project per client brand and use its undiscounted public list prices. The two AI Peekaboo rows are calculator readings for 100 prompts per brand on ChatGPT, Perplexity and Google AI Overviews: every two days for two brands, and daily for 10 brands.
Client brands
Gumshoe Starter
Gumshoe Pro
AI Peekaboo
2
$198/month
$598/month
$150/month, every 2 days
10
$990/month
$2,990/month
$1,500/month, daily
These aren’t like-for-like workloads. Gumshoe includes monthly 480-conversation Visibility Audits and fixed 80-conversation Snapshot Audits, while AI Peekaboo runs the prompt set you build into your plan, as often as you choose. The table shows the structural difference: Gumshoe’s bill rises project by project, while with AI Peekaboo you pay for what you track across the whole subscription.
The Gumshoe 10-brand rows aren’t final quotes: Gumshoe quotes accounts with many brands through sales and offers agencies a discount it doesn’t publish. The AI Peekaboo rows are list prices from its calculator.
Collection method also changes. Gumshoe says it reaches AI platforms through official APIs. AI Peekaboo, Peec AI and Surfer read answers from consumer-facing interfaces, while Scrunch combines browser automation with official platform APIs. Interface tracking aims to show what a logged-out buyer sees, but neither method guarantees better answers.
Gumshoe’s recurring Snapshot Audit is also smaller than its monthly Visibility Audit: four personas, five prompts per persona and four AI platforms, for 80 conversations. Starter runs these snapshots weekly and Pro runs them daily. A team that needs its own prompt set checked every three days, every two days or monthly may prefer a different monitoring setup.
The Gumshoe alternatives worth considering
1. AI Peekaboo: best for agencies tracking several client brands
Gumshoe turns every client brand into a separate project with its own bill. If your agency tracks several brands and sends reports under its own name, AI Peekaboo is the replacement I'd look at first, because all of those brands live in one plan, behind one login, on one invoice.
When a client gains or loses ground in AI answers, you can read the answers themselves and the citation sources behind them. You get evidence to put in front of the client and an obvious job for your team, rather than a percentage that went up or down.
Key features
Keep every client in its own brand, with its own prompts, competitors and dashboard, and see the AI answers and sources behind each score.
Track whichever AI platforms matter to the account, up to 7: ChatGPT, Gemini, Perplexity, Google AI Overviews, Google AI Mode, Microsoft Copilot and Claude API.
Get recommendations, prompt suggestions and content briefs that point to the next questions worth tracking and give your writers a first draft of the plan.
Show prospects what you can do with unlimited pitch workspaces: a single extra brand slot is reused for every prospect's brand you set up.
Give clients a read-only link, or feed the numbers into Looker Studio or your own reporting through the API.
Ask Claude Desktop or Cursor about a client's monthly movement through the MCP server, with the answers and sources taken from your own prompts.
Hook up GA4 and Google Search Console to compare AI visibility with each site's traffic.
Pricing
There is no fixed tier. You set the number of brands, the prompts per brand, the AI platforms (up to 7) and how often prompts run, and the price follows those choices. Claude API costs more per check than the other six platforms, which all cost the same, so see what it does to the total before adding it. Some plans for reference:
Brands
Prompts per brand
AI platforms
How often prompts run
USD monthly
15
40
3
Monthly
30
4
40
3
Weekly
32
2
30
3, one of them Claude API
Weekly
78
4
50
3
Every 3 days
100
1
100
5
Daily
250
10
100
3
Every 3 days
500
Which three platforms you track is entirely up to you, and the cost stays the same unless Claude API is one of them.
An annual plan costs 15% less than paying month to month.
White-label reports and client share links unlock when your plan comes to $100 a month or more.
Bringing more of your agency staff into the account adds nothing, because there is no per-seat charge.
You set how often prompts run once, for the entire account, and every client follows that schedule, so choose it before you build your plan.
If your new workspace has at least 10 prompts per brand and costs under $100 a month, it may be eligible for a 14-day trial with a card on file.
Who should choose it
Choose AI Peekaboo if your agency wants AI visibility reports in its own branding for several clients, with proof of what changed and a clear next move. It fits especially well when each account needs its own prompts but you want a single bill. If you're a brand that just wants to check whether AI answers mention you, and get a few ideas for showing up more, it works for that too.
Skip it if your main question is which buyer persona AI platforms are missing. AI Peekaboo doesn't break results down by persona, so stay with Gumshoe for persona-led analysis, or pick Scrunch Enterprise when you need several personas alongside page and agent-traffic work. Also bear in mind that it delivers briefs rather than finished articles, so the writing still sits with your writers or a writing tool.
2. Profound: best for large enterprise companies
Profound is the enterprise alternative for teams that need AI visibility tracking alongside content, PR and wider marketing work. It isn't the obvious choice for a small agency looking for a low-cost tracker: its public brand plans are a free trial and a custom Enterprise plan, which tells you who it is built for.
Enterprise can track up to nine AI platforms and includes custom prompt tracking, API access, SSO and dedicated support. Profound pitches AI Marketer as a place to research, write, report and collaborate, not only to track visibility. A large company with AEO, content and PR teams can use its agents and workflows for writing and research around the same AI search program.
For agencies, Profound offers Agency Growth and Agency Enterprise. Agency Growth includes ten pitch workspaces each month, while full client workspaces cost $399 a month each. That suits agency networks that pitch prospects and run client workspaces every month, not an agency trying to pool a long list of smaller clients.
Read the Profound review if you're deciding whether those enterprise workflows are worth leaving a more focused tracker.
Key features
Track up to nine AI platforms on Enterprise, with your own prompts, languages and regions.
Use AI Marketer credits, agents, projects and Profound Sheets when your team needs marketing workflows next to tracking.
Connect Agent Analytics to Google Analytics, AWS, Cloudflare and Vercel to see AI agent visits to your site.
Get the API, CSV and JSON exports, SSO and dedicated support on Enterprise.
Run client work with agency mode, pitch workspaces and one combined bill.
Pricing
Profound plan
Price
What you get
Brand Trial
Free for seven days
50 prompts run daily on ChatGPT, Gemini and Google AI Overviews
Brand Enterprise
Custom
Tailored prompt limits and enterprise controls
Agency Growth
No public base price
One client workspace costs $399 a month; five trial workspaces cost $199 a month
Agency Enterprise
Custom
Custom terms
Who should choose it
Choose Profound if you work inside a large enterprise with AEO, content, PR and marketing teams that need enterprise controls and a wider set of workflows. It is also a credible choice for agency networks running a structured program of pitch and client workspaces.
Skip it if you want clear entry pricing for a small team or a simple setup for reporting on many clients. Otterly gives lean teams a smaller starting point, while AI Peekaboo is the more direct option for agencies managing many client brands.
3. Scrunch: best for mid-size and larger brands that need persona filters
Scrunch is the closest alternative if you liked Gumshoe's persona view and also want page audits and AI agent traffic data. It tracks presence, position, sentiment and citations, and lets you filter results by persona, funnel stage, topic and platform.
The catch: Core includes one persona. If you want to compare how several buyer roles get recommended, you need Enterprise, where the persona count is custom. Scrunch also charges per brand, so it doesn't fix the per-client billing that pushes agencies away from Gumshoe.
Scrunch also goes beyond tracking answers. Its plans add page audits and AI agent traffic monitoring, and Agent Pages serves AI agents an AI-optimized version of your site without changing what human visitors see. A mid-size brand that needs to check both AI answers and how AI agents read its site has a solid reason to look at it.
Core costs a lot more than Gumshoe Starter and AI Peekaboo's starting price. At $250 a month it includes one brand workspace, five user licenses, 125 unique prompts and four AI platforms. That price makes sense for an established brand that will use the extra analysis, not a new team tracking a few questions.
Key features
Filter results by persona, funnel stage, topic and platform to study a defined buyer journey.
Track presence, position, sentiment and citations, with recommendations and reporting dashboards.
Run five page audits a month on Core, so you can check single pages next to the answer data.
See AI agent traffic, and on Enterprise use Agent Pages to give AI agents a version of your site they can read easily.
Get three brand workspaces, three pitch workspaces and unlimited user licenses on Agency Core.
Pricing
Scrunch plan
USD monthly
Brand workspaces
Unique prompts
Responses a month
Users
Personas
Core
250
1
125
5,000
5
1
Agency Core
500
3
250
10,000
Unlimited
Not published
Enterprise and Agency Enterprise
Custom
Custom
Custom
Custom
Custom
Custom
Core has a seven-day trial that needs a credit card and turns into a paid subscription unless you cancel.
Who should choose it
Choose Scrunch if your mid-size or larger brand needs persona filters and wants to link AI visibility work with page audits or AI agent traffic. It becomes a serious Gumshoe replacement when your team needs several persona views and can buy Enterprise.
Skip it if your agency's main problem is billing across many small clients. Scrunch bills each tracked brand separately, so AI Peekaboo is simpler for that job. Skip it too if you only need an affordable first look at one brand, where Otterly costs much less to start.
4. Peec AI: best for in-house marketing and SEO teams at one brand
Peec AI fits an in-house marketing or SEO team that wants daily AI search tracking, unlimited users and a dashboard built around one brand. Its plans follow that audience: Starter for SEO and content managers, Pro for SEO teams, and Advanced for marketing teams running several projects.
Every self-serve brand plan includes daily tracking and unlimited users, so five people working on one brand can share the same project without seat charges. The trade-off is that plans cap prompts, AI platforms, countries and projects. That makes Peec AI a clear choice for an internal team, but not automatically the best value for an agency spreading its plan across a mixed client list.
Its Actions area turns findings into suggested work, including writing and drafting tasks. Prompt and competitor suggestions, source analytics, brand attribute scores and gap analysis give your team more direction than a simple mention chart.
Key features
Track daily on three AI platforms you pick on self-serve brand plans, with unlimited team users.
See visibility, position, sentiment and share of voice for your brand and competitors.
Build a useful prompt set with prompt suggestions, personas, source analytics and gap analysis.
Get suggested Actions from your project's findings, including drafting and content improvements.
Connect your reporting with the API from Pro, MCP on all brand plans and Looker Studio from Advanced.
Pricing
Peec AI plan
EUR monthly
EUR monthly, billed annually
Prompts
AI platforms
Projects
Extra AI platform, EUR monthly
Starter
85
70
50
3
1
30
Pro
205
180
150
3
2
70
Advanced
425
360
350
3
5
140
Starter covers one country.
Who should choose it
Choose Peec AI if your in-house marketing or SEO team needs a clear daily dashboard for one brand and you want unlimited seats without jumping to enterprise pricing. It suits teams that will use the suggested actions and source analysis in their ongoing content work.
Skip it if your agency clients need clearly branded reports. Peec AI offers a view-only shareable dashboard on every plan and per-client Data Studio templates on its Scale and Comprehensive agency plans, but it doesn't call either white-label reporting. AI Peekaboo is the better fit when branded client reports are a must.
5. Otterly: best for small businesses and lean marketing teams
Otterly is the sensible choice when Gumshoe feels too expensive or too detailed for a small business tracking one brand. Lite starts at $29 a month and includes 15 prompts, daily tracking, unlimited team members, visibility and sentiment analysis, cited sources and recommendations.
Lite doesn't replace Gumshoe's persona system. It is a simpler tracker for a team that needs a small prompt set and a regular view of coverage, position, citations and competitors. A solo marketer tracking 15 category and comparison questions can start without paying for an agency setup.
Otterly becomes more useful to agencies at Premium, or through its Agency Partner program for Standard and Premium subscribers. Its seven-day trial needs no credit card, so a small team can see whether its prompts produce a report worth watching before paying.
Key features
Track 15, 100 or 400 prompts daily across ChatGPT, Google AI Overviews, Perplexity and Microsoft Copilot.
See brand visibility, sentiment, cited sources, competitors and recommendations on every self-serve plan.
Add unlimited brands, competitors and team members on every plan. Prompts are one shared pool across reports and workspaces.
Use the API, MCP, Data Studio connector and Agent Analytics from Standard.
Send branded Looker Studio reports through the Agency Partner program if you are an eligible Standard or Premium subscriber.
Pricing
Otterly plan
USD monthly
Prompts
What else you get
Lite
29
15
One workspace
Standard
189
100
API, MCP and Data Studio connector
Premium
489
400
Personal onboarding
Standard can add 100 prompts for $99 a month.
Prices are in US dollars, excluding tax.
Who should choose it
Choose Otterly if you are a solo marketer, small business or lean marketing team that needs daily tracking on a small prompt set. It is a cheaper way into ongoing AI visibility tracking than Gumshoe Starter when you don't need persona splits.
Skip it if you manage a large client list and need white-label reports inside the tool. The Agency Partner program offers branded Looker Studio reports, but AI Peekaboo gives agencies a more direct multi-brand, white-label setup.
6. LLM Pulse: best for single-brand teams that want five core AI platforms
LLM Pulse is a practical option for a single-brand team that wants ChatGPT, Perplexity, Google AI Mode, Google AI Overviews and Gemini from its first paid plan. Each prompt you track runs on all five platforms, so you don't have to pick a smaller set.
A two-person team watching 50 buying questions pays €49 a month and sees every answer on all five AI platforms. Weekly checks suit most single-brand teams, and daily checks cost €30 more a month on Starter.
Partner plans are built for much larger agency portfolios: they begin at 25 client projects and 3,600 tracked prompts. LLM Pulse sells white-label reports through Partner or Enterprise deals, with dedicated onboarding, so it isn't the natural first choice for a small agency.
Key features
Track ChatGPT, Perplexity, Google AI Mode, Google AI Overviews and Gemini on every plan.
Run each tracked prompt across all included AI platforms and the countries or languages you set.
Add unlimited team members on every plan, with room for 10 competitors on Starter and 20 on Scale.
Use MCP on every plan, with API access, Data Studio and custom reports from Scale as your work grows.
Get white-label reports, embedded dashboards and your own domain through a quoted Partner or Enterprise deal.
Pricing
LLM Pulse plan
EUR monthly, weekly tracking
EUR monthly, daily tracking
Prompts
Projects
Starter
49
79
50
1
Growth
99
149
150
2
Scale
299
449
450
5
Annual billing costs ten times the monthly price, which LLM Pulse describes as two months free.
The weekly versions of Starter, Growth and Scale come with a 14-day trial once you add a valid payment method. Daily plans start paid.
Who should choose it
Choose LLM Pulse if you have one brand, want the five main AI platforms without picking a smaller set, and want a predictable upgrade path for prompts and projects. It also works if weekly checks are enough today but you may need daily tracking later.
Skip it if your agency needs affordable client reports before it reaches a large portfolio. Its white-label options are quoted through sales on Partner or Enterprise deals. AI Peekaboo fits agencies better at lower client numbers, while Otterly is an easier starting point for a small single-brand team.
7. Surfer: best for content teams already writing in Surfer
Surfer is the logical Gumshoe alternative for a content team that already plans, writes and optimizes content in Surfer. Its AI Tracker sits beside that content work, so your team can go from an AI visibility finding to a content edit without making another tool its main workspace.
AI Search Analytics is Surfer's standalone AI Tracker plan. It covers 50 prompts tracked daily across ChatGPT, Perplexity, Google AI Mode, Google AI Overviews and Gemini, with five brand workspaces, five seats, CSV export, a shareable view-only link and MCP access.
Each branded workspace holds one AI Tracker project. That works for a content team with a clear brand structure, but it isn't a flexible agency subscription with many different client setups. Pick Surfer because a finding in the tracker can become an edit in the same tool and go straight to WordPress, not because it is a strong agency tracker.
Key features
Track five AI platforms with AI Tracker, including visibility score, share of voice, mention gaps and brand sentiment.
Get daily updates on AI Search Analytics, Pro and Peace of Mind, and weekly updates on Standard.
Work from WordPress, Google Docs and Contentful through Surfer's integrations.
Share AI Search Analytics results through view-only links and CSV exports.
Use MCP on AI Search Analytics, Pro, Peace of Mind and Enterprise.
Pricing
Surfer plan
EUR monthly
EUR monthly, billed yearly
AI prompts
How often prompts run
AI platforms
AI Search Analytics
95
82
50
Daily
All five
Standard
119
99
25
Weekly
ChatGPT only
Pro
219
182
50
Daily
All five
Extra AI Tracker prompts come in packs of 10 for $18 a month on Standard, Pro and Peace of Mind. Surfer charges the same figures in USD and EUR.
New accounts get a seven-day trial that needs billing details and turns into the chosen subscription unless you cancel.
Who should choose it
Choose Surfer if your content team already works in Surfer and wants AI visibility data close to its content process.
Skip it if buyer-persona analysis decides the choice, or if you need branded reports for many agency clients. Gumshoe and Scrunch Enterprise are better for persona-led work. AI Peekaboo is better for an agency that needs multi-brand tracking and client-facing reports.
When Gumshoe is still the right choice
Gumshoe remains the right tool when your team needs to see how AI platforms describe your brand to different buyer personas. Its Visibility Audit uses personas, prompts and topics as the working structure. A B2B company can use it to ask whether procurement, operations and technical buyers get different recommendations.
Pro adds Sentiment, Citation and Content Audits, daily Snapshot Audits and more content-generation runs. The persona-led Visibility Audit compares distinct buyer groups, while the additional audits expand the work around those findings.
Gumshoe also provides a free sample audit without a card requirement. Each new customer gets one sample covering four personas, five prompts per persona and four AI platforms. You can see how AI platforms answer four of your buyer types before you pay for a month of tracking.
Move away when project-by-project billing makes your account structure hard to manage, when client reporting needs stronger white-label options, or when you need your own prompt set tracked on a schedule instead of a fixed 80-conversation snapshot.
Choose your replacement from the report you need
Start with the next report your team has to deliver. An agency should write down the client brands it manages, whether each client needs a branded share link and how often each client needs a report. A team with distinct buyer roles should decide whether one persona is enough, because Scrunch Core includes only one and multi-persona work requires Enterprise.
For a single brand on a limited budget, begin with the smallest prompt set that represents real commercial questions. Otterly’s 15-prompt Lite plan or LLM Pulse’s 50-prompt Starter plan can be more useful than paying for capacity your team won’t use. A large enterprise team should instead list the controls and workflows it needs, such as SSO, API access and cross-functional content work.
Good prompt tracking starts with the product, service and buyer problem your team needs to understand. Build a set of ten to twenty commercial questions, including branded, comparison and category questions. If your business serves distinct buyer roles, label each question by role before choosing the tracker.
If you’re still working out where your brand appears, start with a free AI visibility report. It gives you a concrete set of answers to compare against the report you need next.
How we checked this
Last checked: 16 October 2026.
Prices and plan limits: each vendor’s public pricing pages. Features: vendor help docs, product pages and first-party product information.
Frequently asked questions
What is Gumshoe AI?
Gumshoe is an AI search visibility platform that shows how AI platforms describe your brand when people ask for recommendations in your category. Its paid plans organize analysis around projects, with a project defined as a brand plus a focus area. Its Visibility Audit uses buyer personas, prompts and topics, making it useful when you need to compare recommendations received by different buyer groups.
What is the best alternative to Gumshoe AI?
AI Peekaboo is the best Gumshoe alternative for agencies and teams tracking several brands because it supports multiple brands in one subscription where you pay for what you track, and provides white-label reports and client share links from $100 per month. Profound is better for large enterprise companies. Gumshoe remains the better choice when persona-led analysis across several buyer roles is essential.
Which AI visibility tools track buyer personas like Gumshoe?
Scrunch can track buyer personas, but its $250-per-month Core plan includes only one persona. Teams that need to compare several buyer roles need Scrunch Enterprise, where persona capacity is custom. Peec AI includes personas in its prompt setup on every plan, which helps teams write role-specific questions, but Scrunch is the tool that filters results by persona.
How much does Gumshoe cost?
Gumshoe costs $99 per month per project for Starter and $299 per month per project for Pro. A project is a brand plus a focus area, so three product lines on Pro cost $897 per month. Gumshoe’s FAQ says both paid plans include 480 conversations per billing period and bills extra conversations at $0.10 each, although its pricing page says nothing is metered. Ask before planning a heavy month.
Start with your own visibility.
See where your brand appears in AI answers and which competitors get mentioned.